skip navigation

5 Evaluation Tips for Coaches to Help With Team Selection

By TeamGenius, 04/28/23, 10:00AM EDT


Make the best experience possible before the final decisions

Photo Credit: Heather Pollock Photography

At this point, we have given insight on tryout tips for players and parents.

Now that players have done everything they can to be their best during this time of year, it’s time to hit the ice. The attention now turns to the coaches - the ones who will be making the final decisions on who makes the team.

There may be a number of familiar faces at tryouts but plenty of new players who coaches will meet for the first time. Everyone has the same goals in mind and it is up to you to decide who best fits the team you are looking to create.

Here are five tips for coaches to create the best Evaluation experience possible and to make the tryout evaluation process easier.

Use the coaching staff to your advantage

There is power in numbers when it comes to tryouts and having a few extra sets of eyes and ears is beneficial for evaluating players. Assign each member of the coaching staff a group of players or a drill to take charge of. Along with dividing the responsibility so the workload doesn’t become overwhelming, this will also help to create teamwork and trust amongst the coaching staff.

Split players into smaller groups

Dividing players into smaller groups will help them get more reps in on drills and allow for coaching staff to pay more attention to each individual. As mentioned above, each member of the coaching staff can take charge of a group, perhaps by position. Most importantly, have the coaches rotate between each group to get an eye on as many players as possible. This lets players feel like they are able to show the coaches everything they have instead of feeling restricted to limited opportunities.

Don’t forget about the goalies

Perhaps the most important position, the goalies can sometimes be overlooked during tryouts. It is a position that requires knowledge in teaching proper techniques which not every coach has. Do some research on how to properly evaluate netminders and what to look for when evaluating them.

Photo Credit: Heather Pollock Photography

Last year was last year

Every player is coming into tryouts with a clean slate. There will be new faces who have used last season to improve their game and deserve a strong look at making the team this year. On the other hand, some players may feel that they should automatically get a roster spot because they were named to the team in previous seasons. Pick the players that have the best showings and display the most effort.

Be Honest

There is nothing that players and parents want more then honesty. Making the final cuts can be the toughest decisions in tryouts but players just want to hear the truth on how they can improve to make the team next year. Explain why they weren’t a fit for the team this year and what areas they can look to develop.


Share with your friends on Facebook and join the largest network of hockey parents.


TeamGenius is the leading hockey evaluation software provider for minor hockey associations. Founded in 2015, TeamGenius serves thousands of youth athletes, coaches, staff and volunteers with an easy-to-use platform for managing tryouts, clinics, coach & player development programs. TeamGenius is headquartered in Minneapolis, Minnesota. For more information, visit

you may also like

Drill of the Week
Drill of the Week